The landlord taxed on profit he never made

Updated 14 November 2026

An illustrative example based on a common situation. Names and details are invented.

Gary works in IT and earns £60,000. Over fifteen years he bought three flats, each with an interest-only buy-to-let mortgage. The rent comes to £36,000 a year.

What happened

When his fixed rates ended, Gary's mortgage interest rose to around £18,000 a year. With £6,000 of running costs, his real profit was about £12,000.

But under Section 24 he's taxed on £30,000. As a higher-rate taxpayer, his tax bill on the flats came to around £8,400, leaving him about £3,600 for a year of being a landlord. From April 2027, with the property higher rate at 44%, it gets worse.

The fallout

  • Gary had been budgeting on his real profit, not his taxable profit, and was caught out by his tax bill.
  • He considered selling, then realised he'd face capital gains tax too.
  • He wondered about a limited company, but didn't know what it would cost to move.

What could have been different

Gary's situation isn't unusual. With advice earlier, he could have looked at how the flats were owned and financed, and planned his options before the rates and the tax rules changed around him.

Is Section 24 taking more than you think? Try the calculator or request a call back.

Request a call back

Tell us a little about your situation and we'll call you, usually within one working day, to understand what you need. If it would help, we'll then put you in touch with a landlord tax specialist. We'll always tell you who they are before passing on your details. We don't give advice ourselves, and there's no obligation.

We only use your details to respond to you, and only share them with a specialist after telling you who they are. See our privacy notice.